Anna-Mariya OlenglouPublished in:
Scholarly Communication Review
– Volume 2, Number 6 (November-December, 2012)



Keywords: editor, ethic, scientific journal, scientific misconduct, scientific publications


Share:

Abstract:

The article examines the problems of ethics violation principles in the scientific publication field. Despite the significant progress in this area, the issue of scientificpublications’ quality is still unresolved. In this context the principal role is assigned to the editor of the scientific journal as a key mediator in the process of scientificcommunication, responsible for the formation of a scientific publication in a form suitable for further distribution.

---

References:
Zvart, Khub. Professionalnaya etika i nauchnaya kommunikatsiya (Zwart, Hub, Professional ethics and scholarly communication), rezhim dostupa: http:// www.filosofie.science.ru.nl/cv/prof%20 ethics.pdf (obraschenie: 12/3/2011).

Gudrum, Abbi A. i dr. (2001). "Nauchnye publikatsii v epokhu Interneta: analiz tsitirovaniya literatury po vychislitelnoy tekhnike" (Goodrum, Abby A. et al. (2001), “Scholarly publishing in the Internet age: a citation analysis of computer science literature”), "Obrabotka Informatsii i Menedzhment" (Information Processing and Management), № 37, s. 661-675.

Komitet po etike Vsemirnoy assotsiatsii meditsinskikh redaktorov. Eticheskaya politika v otnoshenii publikatsiy dlya meditsinskikh zhurnalov (WAME Publication Ethics Committee, Publication Ethics Policies for Medical Journals), rezhim dostupa: http://www.wame.org/resources/ publication-ethics-policies-for-medical-journals#eddecis (obraschenie: 20/3/2011).

Pimpl, Kennet D. (2002). "Shesty oblastey issledovatelskoy etiki: evristicheskaya ramka dlya otvetstvennogo provedeniya issledovaniya" (Pimple, Kenneth D. (2002), “Six Domains of Research ethics: a Heuristic Framework for the Responsible Conduct of Research”), " Nauchnaya i Inzhenernaya Etika" (Science and Engineering Ethics), № 8, s. 191-205.

Sluzhba Zdravookhraneniya (Public Health Service) (1989), "Obyazannosti institutov-laureatov i institu-tov-soiskateley po prinyatiyu mer i predostavleniyu informatsii o vozmozhnoy nedobrosovestnosti v nauke" («Responsibilities of Awardee and Applicant Institutions for Dealing with and Reporting Possible Misconduct in Science»), "Federalnyy Reestr 54" (Federal Register 54), s. 32446-32451.

King, Sintiya R. "Eticheskie voprosy pri napisanii i publikatsii" (King, Cynthia R., “Ethical issues in writing and publishing”), "Klinicheskiy zhurnal po ukhodu za onkobolnymi" (Clinical Journal of Oncology Nursing), rezhim dostupa: http://www.ons.org/Publications/CJON/ AuthorInfo/WritingSupp/Ethics (obraschenie: 20/3/2011).

Mezhdunarodnoe obschestvo redaktorov zhurnalov po voprosam zavisimosti. "Prakticheskie rekomendatsii po voprosam etiki v publikatsiyakh po problemam zavisimosti: model dlya avtorov, redaktorov zhurnalov i drugikh partnyorov" (ISAJE, “Ethical practice guidelines in addiction publishing: a model for authors, journal editors and other partners”), "Mezhdunarodnoe obschestvo redaktorov zhurnalov po voprosam zavisimosti" (International Society of Addiction Journal Editors), rezhim dostupa: http://www. parint.org/isajewebsite/ethics.htm (obraschenie: 15/2/2011).

Albert, Tim, Vager, Elizabet (2003), "Kak razbiraty spory po voprosam avtorstva: rukovodstvo dlya novyh issledovateley" (Albert, Tim, Wager, Elizabeth (2003), “How to handle authorship disputes: a guide for new researchers”), Doklad Komiteta po izdatelskoy etike (COPE), rezhim dostupa: http://publicationethics.

org/files/u2/2003pdf12.pdf (obraschenie 27/2/2011).

MakKyorcher, Bob i dr. (2007). "Pochemu retsenzenty otvergayut rukopisi" (McKercher, Bob et al. (2007), “Why referees reject manuscripts”), "Zhurnal issledovaniy v oblasti industrii gostepriimstva i turizma" (Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research), Tom 31, № 4, s. 455-470.

Kekh, Tat Khin (1998). "Evolyutsiya industrii knigoizdaniya: strukturnye izmeneniya i strategicheskie posledstviya" (Keh, Tat Hean (1998), “Evolution of the book publishing industry: structural changes and strategic implications”), "Zhurnal istorii menedzhmenta" (Journal of Management History), Tom 4, № 2, s. 104123.

Banu, Kristina (2007), "Izdatelskaya politika i otsenka soderzhaniya meditsinskikh publikatsiy: obespechenie kachestva pechataemyh materialov" (Banou, Christina (2007), “Publishing policy and content evaluation of medical publications: assuring the quality of printed material”), "Trudy 5-y Mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii po IKT v sfere zdravookhraneniya" (Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Information Communication Technologies in Health), ostrov Samos, iyul 2007 g., Natsionalnyy i Kapodistriy-skiy Universitet Afin (National and Kapodistrian University of Athens), Afiny, s. 334-40.

Pauell, Uolter V. (1985). "Popadanie v pechaty: protsess prinyatiya resheniy v nauchnyh izdaniyakh" (Powell, Walter W. (1985), Getting into print: The decisionmaking process in scholarly publishing), Chikago: Izdatelstvo Chikagskogo universiteta, s. 72-78, rezhim dostupa: http://books.google.gr/books?id=uZHr35X jFwIC&printsec=frontcover#v=onepage&q =&f=false (obraschenie: 15/2/2011).

Bogdanovich, Gordana (2003). "Izdatelskaya etika: otnosheniya mezhdu redaktorom i avtorom". (Bogdanovic, Gordana (2003), “Publication ethics: the editor-author relationship”), "Arkhiv onkologii" (Archive of Oncology), tom 11,

№ 3, s. 213-215, rezhim dostupa: http:// www.doiserbia.nb.rs/img/doi/03 54-7310/2003/0354-73100303213B.pdf(obraschenie: 13/1/2011).

Borkovski, Syuzan K., Velsh, Meri Dzhan (1998). "Etika i protsess opublikovaniya otchyotnosti: problemy avtora, retsenzenta i redaktora" (Borkowski, Susan C., Welsh, Mary Jeanne (1998), “Ethics and the Accounting Publishing Process: Author, Reviewer, and Editor Issues”), "Zhurnal Biznes-Etiki" (Journal of Business Ethics), № 17, s. 1785-1803.

Serebnik, Dzhudit (1991). "Vyyavlenie neetichnyh praktik v zhurnalnyh izdaniyakh" (Serebnick, Judith (1991), “Identifying Unethical Practices in Journal Publishing”), "Literaturnye tendentsii" (Library Trends), tom 40, № 2, s. 357-372.

"Mezhdunarodnyy komitet redaktorov meditsinskikh zhurnalov" (International Committee of Medical Journal Editors, ICMJE), rezhim dostupa: http:// www.icmje.org (obraschenie: 3/4/2011).

"Vsemirnaya assotsiatsiya meditsinskikh redaktorov" (World Association of Medical Editors, WAME): http://www.wame. org/.

"Mezhdunarodnoe obschestvo redaktorov zhurnalov po voprosam zavisimosti" (International Society of Addiction Journal Editors, ISAJE): http://www.parint.org (obraschenie: 3/4/2011).

"Sovet nauchnyh redaktorov" (Council of Science Editors, CSE), dostupno po adresu: http://www.councilscienceeditors.org/ i4a/pages/index.cfm?pageid=1 (provereno 3/4/2011).

"Komitet po izdatelskoy etike" (The Committee on Publication Ethics, COPE): http://publicationethics.org/ (obraschenie: 3/4/2011).

Komitet po izdatelskoy etike (COPE), Luchshaya praktika COPE, Rekomendatsii dlya redaktorov zhurnalov, dostupno po adresu: http://publicationethics. org/files/u2/Best_Practice.pdf (obraschenie: 10/1/2011).

"Izdatelstvo Blekvell". Rekomendatsii luchshikh praktik po izdatelskoy etike: tochka zreniya izdatelya (Blackwell Publishing, Best Practice Guidelines on

Publication Ethics: A Publisher's Perspective), rezhim dostupa: http://blackwellpublishing. com/Publicationethics/?site=1 (obraschenie: 15/1/2011).

Vager, Elizabet (2010). "Blok-skhemy komiteta po izdatelskoy etike" (Wager, Elizabeth (2010), “The Committee on Publication Ethics Flowcharts”), "Sunduk" (Chest), № 137, s. 221-223, rezhim dostupa: http://chestjournal.chestpubs. org/content/137/1/221.full (obraschenie: 23/2/2011).

"Otslezhivanie plagiata posredstvom Perekryostnoy proverki" (CrossCheck Plagiarism Screening), dostupno po adresu: http://crossref.org/crosscheck/ crosscheck_for_researchers.html (obraschenie: 29/1/2011).

Meddings, Kirsti (2010). "Vozday dolzhnoe tam, gde eto neobkhodimo: otslezhivanie plagiata v nauchnyh publikatsiyakh" (Meddings, Kirsty (2010), “Credit where credit’s due: plagiarism screening in scholarly publishing”), "Uchyonoe Izdatelstvo" (Learned Publishing), tom 23, № 1, rezhim dostupa: http://xa.yimg.com/kq/ groups/18751725/1128775922/name/cr edits+where+credits+due+plagiarism.pdf (obraschenie: 19/1/2011).

Chzhang, Khelen Yuekhong (2010). "Perekryostnaya proverka: effektivnyy instrument dlya vyyavleniya plagiata" (Zhang, Helen Yuehong (2010), “CrossCheck: an effective tool for detecting plagiarism”), "Uchyonoe Izdatelstvo" (Learned Publishing), tom 23, № 1, s. 9-14.

"Elzevir". Obnaruzhenie plagiata (Elsevier, Plagiarism detection), rezhim dostupa: http://www.elsevier.com/wps/find/ editorsinfo.editors/plagdetect (obraschenie: 23/2/2011).

Sovet nauchnyh redaktorov: otchyoty o ezhegodnyh vstrechakh (2008). "Naskolko legko obmanuty? Naskolko legko razoblachity obman?" (Council of Science Editors: Annual Meeting Reports (2008), “How Easy to Cheat? How easy to Uncover Cheating”), "Nauchnyy redaktor" (Science Editor), tom 31, № 6, rezhim dostupa: http://www.councilscienceeditors.org/ files/scienceeditor/v31n6p186.pdf (obraschenie: 10/4/2011).

Vager, E. i dr. (2009) "Vzglyady redaktorov nauchnyh zhurnalov na etiku publikatsiy: rezultaty mezhdunarodnogo obzora" (Wager, E. et al. (2009), “Science journal editors’ views on publication ethics: results of an international survey”), "Zhurnal meditsinskoy etiki" (J Med Ethics), № 35, s. 348-353.

Tekseyra, Avrora K. i dr. (2010). "Kto pravit pravitelem? Po povodu nedobrosovestnosti redaktorov zhurnalov" (Teixeira, Aurora A. C. et al. (2010), “Who Rules the Ruler? On the Misconduct of Journal Editors”), "Zhurnal nauchnoy etiki" (Journal of Academic Ethics), № 8, s. 111128.

Godli, Fiona (2004). "Boryba s redaktorskoy nedobrosovestnostyyu". (Godlee, Fiona (2004), “Dealing with editorial misconduct”), "BMZh" (BMJ), tom 329, rezhim dostupa: http://www.bmj.com/ content/329/7478/1301.full (obraschenie: 10/4/2011).